Robin of Sherwood, broadcast from 1984 to 1986, remains a landmark in British television for its atmospheric blend of medieval myth, folklore, and political unrest. Central to its legacy are the two actors who portrayed Robin Hood: Michael Praed and Jason Connery. The series’ decision to recast the role midway is still the subject of debate. Each actor brought a contrasting interpretation of the legendary outlaw, shaped as much by the narrative arc as by personal style.
Michael Praed as Robin of Loxley
Character Origins and Style
Praed played the original Robin, a Saxon commoner chosen by Herne the Hunter to stand against Norman tyranny. This version of Robin was deeply rooted in mysticism and pagan lore, more folk hero than historical outlaw.
Performance and Presence
Praed gave Robin a brooding intensity. He was charismatic but carried the weight of destiny with solemn conviction. His Robin felt almost pre-Christian, elemental, and driven more by fate than personal ambition.
Impact and Departure
Praed’s departure at the end of Series Two in “The Greatest Enemy” was a bold narrative decision. His death added a tragic dimension that elevated the mythic quality of the character. His legacy haunted the remaining episodes, and for many fans, his Robin remains the definitive incarnation.
Watch: The Greatest Enemy – Episode with Michael Praed
Jason Connery as Robert of Huntingdon
Character Origins and Style
Connery’s Robin, introduced in Series Three, was a nobleman who turned his back on privilege to become an outlaw. Where Praed’s Robin was chosen by a higher power, Connery’s character made a conscious decision to take up the mantle.
Performance and Development
Connery lacked the ethereal presence of his predecessor but brought a more reflective, grounded approach. His Robin was strategic, thoughtful, and often conflicted. He grew into the role across the series, shifting from uncertain inheritor to credible leader.
Tonal Shift in the Series
With Connery’s arrival, the show leaned more heavily into political themes and personal responsibility, moving away from the overt mysticism of the earlier seasons. The shift suited Connery’s interpretation, allowing his Robin to evolve on his own terms rather than imitating Praed.
Watch Jason Connery from “Time of the Wolf”
Comparative Legacy
Myth vs Humanity
Praed’s Robin was a symbol, almost supernatural in scope, embodying the spirit of the forest and the oppressed. Connery’s Robin was more relatable, a man rather than a legend, trying to live up to a symbol he didn’t create.
Cultural Impact
Praed’s episodes left a stronger cultural footprint, aided by the emotional intensity of his storyline and the boldness of his character’s end. Connery’s contribution is often underrated but was essential to the series’ continuation.
Audience Reception
Fans tend to favour Praed for the sheer gravitas he brought to the role. Yet many who stayed with the series found Connery’s Robin increasingly compelling. His portrayal added a different kind of depth—one of resilience, growth, and inheritance.
The Seven Swords takeaway
Michael Praed gave Robin of Sherwood its heart. Jason Connery gave it its future. Choosing one over the other depends on what one values more in the legend: the mythic archetype or the fallible successor. The series worked so well because it made room for both.
