The Battle of Evesham marked the brutal turning point in the Second Barons’ War, fought between rebellious nobles led by Simon de Montfort and the forces loyal to King Henry III and his son, Prince Edward (later Edward I). It was not just a battle, but a political reckoning that ended in massacre and retribution. The clash took place near the town of Evesham in Worcestershire, with consequences that reshaped English governance and monarchy.
Background
Following de Montfort’s remarkable victory at the Battle of Lewes in 1264, he effectively ruled England in the king’s name. His reformist agenda, however, earned him many enemies among the baronial class. Prince Edward escaped captivity in May 1265 and rallied royalist forces. What followed was a swift and calculated campaign to destroy de Montfort’s regime, culminating in the decisive battle at Evesham.
Forces
| Side | Leader(s) | Estimated Troop Numbers | Composition |
|---|---|---|---|
| Royalists | Prince Edward, Earl of Gloucester | Approx. 10,000 | Cavalry, infantry, Welsh auxiliaries |
| Rebel Barons (Montfortians) | Simon de Montfort, his son Simon the Younger | Approx. 5,000 | Cavalry, infantry, Welsh and marcher troops |
De Montfort was waiting for reinforcements from his son Simon the Younger, but these never arrived in time. Meanwhile, Edward used feigned flags and swift manoeuvres to trap the older Montfort in a pincer between the Avon River and Green Hill.
Leaders and Command Structure
Royalist Commanders
- Prince Edward (later Edward I) – Architect of the royalist strategy, aggressive and uncompromising
- Gilbert de Clare, Earl of Gloucester – Provided vital support after turning against de Montfort
- Roger Mortimer – Key Marcher lord who executed much of the post-battle reprisals
Rebel Commanders
- Simon de Montfort, Earl of Leicester – Veteran of crusades and Parliamentarian reformer
- Simon the Younger – Delayed with reinforcements; arrived too late
- Peter de Montfort – Loyal lieutenant who died at Evesham
Arms and Armour
| Category | Royalist Forces | Montfort’s Forces |
|---|---|---|
| Armour | Chainmail hauberks, iron helmets (nasal helms), padded gambesons | Similar chainmail and helms, some lighter equipment |
| Weapons | Arming swords, lances, maces, longbows | Arming swords, crossbows, axes, spears |
| Cavalry | Heavy Norman-style cavalry, well-trained | Smaller cavalry contingent, outnumbered |
| Infantry | Professional soldiers and Welsh footmen | Town militias, marcher men, some Welsh units |
The royalist knights had the advantage in terms of both numbers and quality. Edward’s use of mounted archers, combined with tightly coordinated charges, proved devastating.
The Battle Unfolds: Timeline
- Early morning, 4 August 1265: Prince Edward reaches Evesham and positions his troops on the high ground near Green Hill.
- Mid-morning: De Montfort realises he is surrounded. His son’s banners are spotted in the royalist ranks, a deception that confirmed the trap.
- Late morning: Edward launches a downhill assault. The rebel line quickly buckles.
- By midday: Simon de Montfort is slain in battle. His body is mutilated. His head and genitals are sent to Mortimer’s wife.
- Afternoon: The remaining rebel troops are massacred. The River Avon is reportedly clogged with bodies.
This was not a conventional battle. It was a targeted elimination. Chroniclers refer to it as a “butchery.”
Archaeology
The battlefield near Evesham Abbey and Green Hill has produced limited finds due to urban development and agricultural use. However:
- Skeletons with trauma wounds have been unearthed near the site of the abbey, possibly linked to the post-battle slaughter.
- Arrowheads and spur fragments recovered suggest a cavalry-dominated encounter.
- A probable mass grave was identified near the presumed site of the rebel retreat, but has not been fully excavated.
Evesham remains one of the more elusive medieval battlefields in terms of physical evidence, largely due to the scale of destruction and landscape changes.
Contemporary Quotes
- “They made a great slaughter… none they spared.” – Chronicle of Bartholomew Cotton
- “The body of the noble earl, Simon, was shamefully mangled… no pity was shown.” – Annales Monastici
- “God hath judged between them.” – Roger Mortimer, according to legend, upon viewing de Montfort’s corpse
- “Blessed be the Lord who hath avenged the king’s cause.” – Royalist cleric quoted in post-battle records
These quotes reflect the deeply polarised views of de Montfort: to some a martyr, to others a usurper.
Legacy
Evesham was more than a military victory. It symbolised the violent rejection of radical reform and ushered in a royalist resurgence. Though Prince Edward would later implement many governance reforms as king, they came under the crown’s control rather than through baronial rebellion.
Simon de Montfort’s death did not erase his legacy. He is often cited as a father of parliamentary government in England, and his reforms sowed ideas that would surface again in later centuries.
The Seven Swords takeaway
The Battle of Evesham was a ruthless encounter driven by political vendetta, not simply military rivalry. It crushed a movement, slaughtered a generation of reformist nobility, and restored the monarchy’s grip on power. Its legacy is tangled in violence, principle, and the unpredictable shape of English constitutional history.
Watch the documentary:
