Captain William Kidd remains one of the most debated figures of the Golden Age of Piracy. Once a respected privateer, he ended his career accused of piracy and hanged in chains on the banks of the River Thames. His story is one of blurred lines, conflicting testimonies, and political expediency.
Early Life and Background
William Kidd was born in Dundee, Scotland, around 1654. Little is known about his early years, but by the 1680s he had moved to New York and established himself among its merchant elite. He married Sarah Bradley Cox, a wealthy widow, and became a shipowner and privateer. Kidd earned a reputation as a capable captain during various campaigns against the French in the West Indies and off the coast of North America.
Privateering Commission
In 1695, Kidd received a commission from the English Crown to hunt pirates and French vessels. Backed by influential Whig politicians including Lord Bellomont, he captained the Adventure Galley, a hybrid ship fitted with both sails and oars. His mission was to patrol the Indian Ocean, a region plagued by piracy.
Shift to Piracy
After months of sailing and failing to capture legitimate targets, Kidd’s crew grew restless. Morale declined and discipline faltered. Some scholars suggest the shift to piracy may have been a desperate act to appease his increasingly mutinous men. In 1698, Kidd captured the Armenian merchant vessel Quedagh Merchant, a rich prize laden with gold, silk and opium, but one that sailed under a French pass.
Although Kidd claimed this justified the seizure under his commission, the ship belonged to Indian merchants, not France. The act infuriated the powerful East India Company and the Mughal Empire, putting political pressure on the British government to act.
Weapons and Ships
- Primary Ship: Adventure Galley
- 34 metres long
- Armed with 34 cannons
- Equipped with oars to navigate windless seas
- Seized Vessel: Quedagh Merchant
- Merchant ship carrying high-value goods
- Later renamed Adventure Prize
Kidd was armed primarily with flintlock pistols, cutlasses, and muskets. As a privateer captain, he relied more on boarding and intimidation than full naval engagements.
Battles and Encounters
Kidd engaged in few formal battles, preferring to intimidate or chase down targets. The seizure of the Quedagh Merchant remains his most significant act of aggression. He also reportedly clashed with Moorish vessels in the Red Sea and pursued lesser ships off Madagascar.
Bounty and Treasure
Estimates vary, but the total value of the Quedagh Merchant’s cargo exceeded £70,000 at the time, equivalent to millions today. Kidd buried some of this treasure on Gardiners Island, off Long Island, New York. This deposit was later recovered by authorities and used as evidence in his trial.
Rumours of further buried treasure persist but remain unproven. The Quedagh Merchant itself was found in shallow waters off the Dominican Republic in 2007, confirming parts of Kidd’s route.
Contemporary Quotes
“I am the innocentest of them all, only I have been sworn against by perjured men.”
– William Kidd, at his trial, 1701
“He who robs the robber hath a thousand excuses.”
– Attributed to a contemporary pamphlet defending Kidd
“Kidd’s name shall be a terror to posterity.”
– Lord Chancellor Somers, as Parliament debated his fate
Arrest, Trial and Execution
Kidd returned to the American colonies in 1699, hoping to clear his name. He was arrested in Boston on the orders of Lord Bellomont and sent to England. His trial was politically charged. The government, under pressure to appease the East India Company, made Kidd a scapegoat.
He was found guilty of piracy and murder, the latter for killing a mutinous gunner named William Moore. Kidd was hanged on 23 May 1701 at Execution Dock in Wapping. The rope snapped on the first attempt, a moment considered ominous, but the second attempt succeeded. His body was tarred and hung in chains along the Thames as a warning to others.
Legacy
William Kidd’s story sits on the edge of myth and fact. Some view him as a pirate betrayed by the same elites who once empowered him. Others see him as a rogue who used his commission as cover for private gain. His name has endured in folklore, films, and treasure hunts across the Atlantic world.
His execution marked a turning point in Britain’s approach to maritime law and imperial trade. The government tightened control over privateering and moved toward more formal naval power.
Where to See Relics
- Museum of London Docklands: Items relating to Kidd’s execution site
- The Whydah Pirate Museum (USA): Displays on piracy and Kidd’s era
- Children’s Museum of Indianapolis: Hosts the cannon from the wreck of Quedagh Merchant
The wreck site near Catalina Island, Dominican Republic, is protected and considered a significant underwater archaeological site.
William Kidd remains a controversial figure. Whether reckless adventurer or political casualty, his fate reflected the cutthroat world of empire, commerce, and maritime law at the turn of the 18th century.
Watch the documentary:
