Who were the emperors that dragged Rome into chaos?
The Roman Empire saw rulers of brilliance and reform, but it also endured emperors whose reigns veered into incompetence, cruelty, or delusion. While some brought brief glory before decline, others left nothing but wreckage. This article traces the most notorious emperors from bad to catastrophic, focusing on their policies, behaviour, and long-term damage to Rome.
1. Commodus (r. 180–192)
The self-styled gladiator who confused Rome with a stage
- Son of Marcus Aurelius, Commodus marked the beginning of imperial decline.
- He abandoned military campaigns and delegated power to corrupt favourites.
- Famous for fighting as a gladiator, he treated the empire like a personal circus.
- His obsession with being a living god distorted the role of emperor into spectacle.
- Eventually strangled in his bath after a failed poisoning attempt.
Legacy:
His reign ended the golden age of the Antonines and pushed Rome into political instability and civil war.
2. Elagabalus (r. 218–222)
The eccentric priest-emperor who scandalised the capital
- Became emperor at just 14, largely thanks to a power play by his grandmother Julia Maesa.
- Prioritised religious reform centred around the Syrian sun god Elagabal, ignoring Rome’s traditions.
- Alienated the Senate, military, and populace through extravagance and erratic behaviour.
- His court was infamous for lavish feasts, odd rituals, and controversial relationships.
Legacy:
Assassinated by the Praetorian Guard. His body was dumped in the Tiber. His rule was later used as a byword for decadence.
3. Caracalla (r. 198–217)
A tyrant cloaked in military authority
- Best known for the Constitutio Antoniniana, granting Roman citizenship to all free men in the empire, partly to boost tax revenue.
- Ordered the murder of his brother Geta and thousands of his supporters.
- Obsessed with Alexander the Great, he attempted military conquests that stretched the treasury.
- His paranoia deepened, leading to purges of advisors and allies.
Legacy:
Despite administrative reforms, his brutality overshadowed his reign. He was killed by a disaffected officer.
4. Caligula (r. 37–41)
From promising prince to maniacal ruler in less than a year
- Began with goodwill, but an illness early in his reign seemed to trigger erratic behaviour.
- He claimed divinity, built golden statues of himself, and reportedly made his horse a priest (though this may have been satire).
- Lavish spending depleted the treasury, while executions and humiliations of senators alienated Rome’s elite.
- Known for theatrical cruelty, including watching executions as entertainment.
Legacy:
Assassinated by the Praetorian Guard. His death exposed the fragility of the imperial system.
5. Nero (r. 54–68)
Artist, arsonist, and architect of his own downfall
- Began with promise under the guidance of Seneca and Burrus, but slid into vanity and paranoia.
- Allegedly watched Rome burn while performing on stage, though the story remains contested.
- Blamed Christians for the fire and launched the empire’s first organised persecution.
- Spent lavishly on his Domus Aurea palace while provinces seethed with rebellion.
- Executed his mother Agrippina and many rivals, real or imagined.
Legacy:
Nero’s suicide ended the Julio-Claudian dynasty. His reign left the empire in chaos, triggering the Year of the Four Emperors.
6. Domitian (r. 81–96)
Autocrat cloaked in efficiency
- Strong administrator who secured the borders and revalued Roman coinage.
- However, he ruled as a tyrant, demanding to be called Dominus et Deus (Lord and God).
- Relentless use of informants and secret police made Rome a city of fear.
- His paranoia led to mass executions, particularly of senators and intellectuals.
Legacy:
Murdered by palace insiders. His name was condemned and erased from public monuments.
7. Valerian (r. 253–260)
The emperor captured like a common prisoner
- Faced multiple invasions and crises, including a devastating plague.
- Taken captive by the Persian king Shapur I in battle, an unparalleled humiliation.
- Lived out his days in captivity, reportedly used as a human footstool by his captors.
Legacy:
His capture shocked the Roman world and shattered the image of imperial invincibility.
8. Honorius (r. 393–423)
The emperor who lost the Western Empire’s soul
- Reigned as the Western Empire collapsed around him.
- His court, based in Ravenna, remained out of touch with the crisis in Rome.
- Failed to support Stilicho adequately, then executed him. This removed Rome’s last great general.
- Watched as the Visigoths, led by Alaric, sacked Rome in 410.
Legacy:
Honorius presided over irreversible decline. His reign marked the transition from empire to fragmentation.
9. Maximinus Thrax (r. 235–238)
The brute who crushed everything but his enemies
- A soldier-emperor with no senatorial background, he ruled through military strength alone.
- Imposed crushing taxes to fund campaigns, leading to widespread resentment.
- Never set foot in Rome during his reign.
- Murdered by his own troops after a failed siege of Aquileia.
Legacy:
His rule began the Crisis of the Third Century, a near-collapse of imperial authority.
10. Licinius (r. 308–324)
Forgotten but treacherous
- Co-emperor with Constantine, but increasingly ruled as a despot in the East.
- Waged war against Christians despite prior agreements.
- Lost decisively at the Battle of Chrysopolis.
Legacy:
Executed despite surrendering. Overshadowed by Constantine, but contributed to decades of civil war and division.
The Seven Swords Takeaway
Rome endured its worst moments not just through invasions or plagues, but through the failings of its own emperors. From incompetence to outright madness, each of these rulers weakened the empire in their own way. Some were undone by their own ambition, others by fear, greed, or delusion. The empire survived many of them, but not without cost.
Watch the documentary:
